ESALogo.gif (3595 bytes)

Seal Forum

This document is a compilation of technical papers from leading rotating equipment engineers across the globe, providing a balanced view of mechanically-sealed and sealless systems in a wide range of applications. The user experts give unbiased reports about their own experience with the various options available for rotating equipment.

The document is available in English and German language versions. Please click one of the images below to see a list of contents:

English

Deutsch

     

This document is a joint publication of the ESA and FSA.

Copies are available from most ESA Mechanical Seals Division Member Companies. See ... List of Division Members

In the document, the user experts confirm that the vast majority of rotating equipment is mechanically-sealed and the justification for this becomes obvious once the total cost of ownership is considered.

Presentations prepared by leading consultants show a decided advantage for operating mechanically-sealed equipment over sealless equipment based on the total cost of ownership. Life cycle cost evaluations can help predict the most cost-effective solutions, minimise waste, and maximise energy efficiency. These evaluations address all costs associated with the acquisition of the equipment as well as owning and operating the equipment over its full life period. A life cycle cost evaluation should consider the following key areas:

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     initial capital acquisition costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     installation and commissioning costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     energy costs for the operating process

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     general operating costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     repair and maintenance costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     downtime costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     environmental costs

    bullet1.gif (109 bytes)     decommissioning and disposal costs at the end of the life cycle

 While many organisations base their selections primarily on the initial acquisition and installation costs, other costs required to sustain the equipment through their life cycles could be anywhere from 2 to 20 times these initial costs. Time, money and all practicable alternatives must be considered to help predict the most cost-effective solution.

back to Mechanical Seals Division

esatwist2.gif (21250 bytes)